I know many of your characters so vaguely.
They are archetypes to me.
That's why I got bent out of shape when your Character started spouting science. I did not know her well enough to know if that seemed in character to me, but it conflicted with the archetype I had formed for her (An intuitive, sensitive person.)
The Watchman and his people are fairly clear, as I see their thoughts and feelings and history nearly as well as I feel my own characters.
Ideally, I should know your characters well enough to guess how they would react to things.
“She'd become a governess. It was one of the few jobs a known lady could do. And she'd taken to it well. She'd sworn that if she did indeed ever find herself dancing on rooftops with chimney sweeps she'd beat herself to death with her own umbrella.”
― Hogfather